Read the student's claim
x2+x3=x5 The student has added the indices 2 and 3 to get 5.
Recall when indices are added
am×an=am+n Indices are only added when powers are multiplied, not when terms are added.
Identify the operation here
This is an addition of two different terms, not a multiplication.
Check whether the terms are alike
x2 and x3 The terms have different indices, so they are not like terms and cannot be combined.
Test the claim with a number
let x=2 Substitute a value to test whether the claim could be true.
Work out the left-hand side
22+23=4+8=12 Two squared plus two cubed is four plus eight, which is twelve.
Work out the claimed answer
Two to the power 5 is thirty-two.
Compare the two values
Twelve does not equal thirty-two, so the claim is false.
Explain why
addition=multiplication You may only add indices when multiplying powers of the same base.
Consider the multiplication case
x2×x3=x5 If it had been a product, the answer x to the power 5 would be correct.
State what can be done
x2+x3=x2(1+x) The sum can only be factorised, not written as a single power.
Rule out the multiply-indices idea
x2⋅x3=x6 Multiplying the indices to get 6 is also wrong; indices are added when multiplying.
Rule out the doubling idea
x2+x3=2x5 The two terms are not equal, so they cannot be counted as two of the same term.
Confirm the correct statement
cannot be simplified to a single power The expression x squared plus x cubed cannot be written as one power of x.
Choose the answer
option describing that indices add only when multiplying The correct statement explains that indices are added only when multiplying.